08 August 2006

What Sticks

From AdAge.Com, a review of the forthcoming book What Sticks, by Rex Briggs and Greg Stuart, highlights some of the dysfunction that translates in millions billions of dollars wasted in advertising and marketing efforts.

From the review:
Unable to define success Ad agencies, the target of nearly nonstop flagellation both self-inflicted and otherwise in the past decade, may find some solace in the book. It pins much of the blame for marketing's woes on marketers and their failure to even define success for campaigns at the outset -- much less measure it properly on the back end. Of the 36 marketers the authors researched, only ttwo -- P&G and Cingular -- had a clear definition of success for each marketing effort at the outset, Mr. Briggs said in an interview.

Some marketers may argue BLINK, but it’s the definition of group think:

The authors discovered that many longstanding axioms of media planning were based on nothing more than hunch and legend. They reveal how frequently marketers disregard research when it doesn't jibe with their own opinions -- or seek out research that does.

To what extent are you defining success before a campaign starts? Do you know why your customers (suspects, prospects, returning, or otherwise) are motivated to utilize your product or service? $53.5 billion in waste on motivation alone, according to Rex Briggs (in an audio interview on his company's site). Not understanding the motivation then translates into poorly designed message. Briggs claims over $38 billion then is wasted as the message doesn’t account for motivation. That’s over $88 billion in advertising spend lost due to an inability to understand and message to its core audience.

I used to work with a group of web developers who used the work motto "suck less." For marketers wasting less would be a healthy start to providing greater value for their organization or clients.

UPDATE 8/14/06 - More Audio (AdAge interviews Greg Stuart)

07 August 2006

50 Million Blogs Can't Be Wrong


David Sifry's "State of the Blogosphere" shows a phenomenal growth curve and is nicely illustrated with graphs from Technorati.
The blogosphere has been doubling in size every 6 months or so. It is over 100 times bigger than it was just 3 years ago.

Podcasting the death knell for HD Radio; TV losing its grasp

Traditional media in its digital and analog formats are losing their lifeforce – all good things, I suppose. Identities and mediums have a shelf life and online media is putting older formats in the old media home.

First, Stephen Hill claims HD Radio is DOA and podcasting is to blame.


"System thought leaders and power players are finally united in the realization that digital delivery will happen most powerfully online and will do a far better job of supporting the underlying public service mission of the industry. They are now actively working on a comprehensive plan to do it by aggregating both infrastructure and content to support emerging composite business models," says Hill.
The convergence of media and the changing of channels reshuffles the deck. Reaching an intended demographic becomes more challenging. McKinsey is reporting that TV is losing its power and reach. From AdAge:


That shocking statistic, delivered to the company's Fortune 100 clients in a report on media proliferation, assumes a 15% decrease in buying power driving by cost-per-thousand rate increases; a 23% decline in ads viewed due to switching off; a 9% loss of attention to ads due to increased multitasking and a 37% decrease in message impact due to saturation. (snip)

According to Forrester Research's most recent North American Consumer Technology Adoption Study, people ages 18 to 26 spend more time online than watching TV and are adopting new technology faster than any other generation. Because of that, they tend to be more receptive to blog, podcast and mobile-web ads.

Reinforcing the difficulty in capturing the attention of the youth demographic, the LA Times describes how 12-24-year olds are simply underwhelmed. No wonder MTV gave up on videos they're like three minutes long, man.

While TV’s clarity and simplicity, which may seem like elegance to some and a dinosaur to others, will retain viewers for some time – especially those over 30, it appears like revenues for online venues should continue to climb at an accelerated pace.

Do you know how to translate your brand online?

Thanks to honorary field agent Cory for the Stephen Hill article.

06 August 2006

The SOAP Virus Spreads


Snakes On A Plane (SOAP) - the viral movie sensation of the year continues to shine. From the blog-driven hype machine that landed a cover on EW to calls from the star SOAP is on a roll. You can now construct a call from Samuel L. Jackson to a friend, co-worker, ex-spouse, etc. reminding them to see the best movie ever on August 18th.

This viral campaign is spreading so fast the CDC is nervous.

(hat tip to Kevin at Soflow for the 411 on the SOAP call)

04 August 2006

iPod will continue to spread; satellite radio slumps

Reaching drivers just became a bit more difficult.

Apple has inked with car manufacturers, including BMW, Acura, Audi, Ferrari, Honda, Nissan and Volkswagen. This will continue to expand the presence of iPod (and possibly bring other Apple products along for the ride as a latent effect). This is a blow to traditional radio and satellite radio.

Apple has sold over 58 million iPods. It works, it's a good product, it's easy and it turns out very viral. Now, let's look at another form of digital media -- satellite radio. Even with Howard "King of All Media" Stern, the industy slumps, sags, and drags. Apple making sure that it is even easier to use your iPod in the car is another blow for the folks over at Sirius and XM who continue to experience losses. Subscriber acquisition costs seem to play a huge factor here.

So the question for marketing professionals: How are you going to reach your target market during drive time? According to Arbitron, about one-third of all radio listening takes place in the car.

Media convergence and the blurring of channel lines becomes more and more interesting. Ten years ago, did you think you’d be able to take your music, calendar, contacts, and videos with you in a phone or iPod? Don't say yes because you hadn't heard of iPod and your phone had limited coverage -- you were happy that it had an address book. You could call all of your friends and brag about your new Sony Discman.

26 July 2006

Ram Rash or How I Got A Case of the Dodge in Europe

Ram Rash?

This seems to be the flip side of the Dr Z campaign in Europe, as Daimler-Chrysler starts to come together as a unified company. Is Ram Rash contagious? What's the viral capability? Ram Rash was first identified by honorary field agent Jason.

Is Dr. Z too Euro for America? Is Dodge too American for Europe?

UPDATE: JULY 31 From AdAge

It seems as though a basic step in uncertainty reduction was missed, as seven of 10 potential consumers surveyed didn't know that Dr. Z is a real person, let alone the CEO. Ouch. $221mm has been spent on the campaign so far.




24 July 2006

The Hubster Disaster or Co-Opted to Death

I went back to the WalMart social marketing site to see how the School Your Way/ Hubster disaster is taking shape. Perhaps I'm a glutton for punisment.

I have to believe that most traffic to this site is analogous to a gawker’s delay. It’s a car wreck – a completely sublime, yet intriguing, event that’s awful. You try and you try, but you can’t take your eyes off of it. This campaign is like Mike Peters (Jon Favreau) vs. the answering machine in SWINGERS. Painful and entertaining -- they'r not going to do something that stupid again...oh, yes they are.

My favorite part is the FAQ section of the site:
WHO’S BEHIND THIS GENIUS WEB DESTINATION?
The guys from Wal-Mart and Sony®
teamed up to bring you all the sweet stuff you’ll find on the HUB!


Sweet indeed.

Is Sony a new kiss of death when it comes to youth marketing? They teamed up with Ford for the ill-fated Flash Mobs.

22 July 2006

Zune - iPod Throwdown

Microsoft Zune to compete with Apple's iPod. In hindsight, this post from a few months back must have been when the creative teams at Microsoft were working to develop Zune's packaging.

How well will Zune do? Will it crash as much as most Windows products? Will it fair better than the Sony Bean, the Dell DJ, etc.?